Easy Homemade Recipes

  • Recipe Box
    • Blog
  • About Me
    • Contact
    • Work With Me
menu icon
go to homepage
  • Recipe Box
  • Subscribe
  • About Me
  • Contact
subscribe
search icon
Homepage link
  • Recipe Box
  • Subscribe
  • About Me
  • Contact
×
Home » All Recipes » Cookies

How to Make a Tempting Christmas Cookie Tray Plus Recipes

Published: Apr 1, 2023 by AmyG Modified On: Feb 13, 2025. This post may contain affiliate links. 3 Comments.

Baking cookies for your Christmas Cookie Tray has been a holiday tradition for many families for generations. Whether it's gingerbread, sugar cookies, or shortbread, the smell of freshly baked cookies in the house is enough to get everyone in the festive spirit.

With so many cookie recipes out there, it can be difficult to decide which ones to make for the annual tray with homemade Christmas Cookies. That's why we've put together a list of our top cookie recipes that are sure to impress your family and friends this holiday season.

From classic Italian favorites to unique and creative twists, these cookies are sure to become a new holiday tradition for your family.

Christmas cookie tray with an assortment of cookies.
Jump to:
  • Tips for Planning Your Perfect Christmas Cookie Tray and Giveaways
  • How to Store and Transport Your Christmas Cookies
  • How to Arrange Cookies on a Christmas Cookie Tray
  • Common Tools and Equipment Needed for Making Cookies
  • Recipes for The Best Christmas Cookie Trays
  • Desserts You'll Fall For
  • PIN IT Here
  • Comments

Tips for Planning Your Perfect Christmas Cookie Tray and Giveaways

After Thanksgiving, I usually start to think about what cookies I'm going to be baking for my Christmas cookie tray and my Christmas treat bags.

I love giving away Christmas cookies in treat bags whenever I can.

Planning ahead which cookies to make for my Christmas cookie tray makes it much easier for me to organize what supplies I need and schedule time to bake my Christmas cookies leading up to the holidays.

Consider the following when planning on making cookies for Christmas cookie trays:

Variety: Consider baking a variety of cookies with different shapes, colors, and flavors to make the cookie tray more visually appealing and interesting.

Quantity: Determine the number of guests and how many cookies each person is likely to eat to ensure you have enough cookies to go around.

Time: Plan ahead and allow enough time to bake and decorate the cookies. Some cookies may require chilling or resting time, so make sure you read the recipe ahead of time.

Storage: Consider the storage options for the cookies. Some cookies may need to be stored in an airtight container to maintain their freshness, while others may need to be stored in the refrigerator or freezer.

How to Store and Transport Your Christmas Cookies

If you have ever made cookies to add to Christmas cookie trays you want to gift, you know what it feels like to be proud of your work.  The last thing you want to do is to have your hard work discarded by improper storage or wrapping.

Here are some tips on storage for your cookies, whether you are giving them away immediately or storing them to give away later.

  1. Cooling Racks: Allow cookies to cool completely on a cooling rack before storing them. This helps to prevent moisture from building up and ruining your cookies.
  2. Airtight Containers: Store cookies in airtight containers to maintain their freshness. You can also separate the cookies with parchment paper to prevent sticking.
  3. Cookie Tins: Cookie tins are perfect for storing and transporting Christmas cookies. They come in various sizes and designs, making them a festive addition to your cookie tray.
  4. Plastic Wrap: You can wrap cookies individually in plastic wrap to prevent them from drying out. This method is especially useful for delicate cookies.
  5. Freezer Bags: If you need to transport cookies for a longer period, consider using freezer bags. These bags are sturdy and will protect your cookies from getting crushed.
  6. Decorative Boxes or Treat Bags: For an elegant touch, you can package your Christmas cookies in decorative boxes. These boxes come in various shapes and sizes and can be found at craft stores or online.
  7. Hand Carry: If you're traveling with cookies, consider carrying them in a hand-carry bag to prevent them from getting crushed or damaged during transit.
  8. Car Trunk: If you're transporting a large amount of cookies, consider using your car trunk. Place the cookies in a sturdy container and secure it to prevent it from moving around while you're driving.

How to Arrange Cookies on a Christmas Cookie Tray

When it comes to putting together a cookie tray for a special occasion or holiday, arranging the cookies can make all the difference. A well-arranged tray not only looks visually appealing, but it can also help to showcase the unique features of each type of cookie.

Proper arrangement also makes it easier to choose which cookie you want to try first and help to prevent cookies from getting crushed or damaged during transport or serving.

Here are a few tips on arranging cookies on a cookie tray.

  1. Group by type: Arrange cookies into groups based on their type, such as chocolate chip, sugar cookies, or gingerbread.
  2. Arrange by size: Place larger cookies in the center and smaller cookies around them.
  3. Create a color scheme: Arrange cookies in a way that creates a visually appealing color scheme.
  4. Use height variation: Use stands or pedestals to create height variation and add visual interest.
  5. Add decor: Add decorative elements, such as holiday-themed napkins or ornaments, to enhance the display.

Common Tools and Equipment Needed for Making Cookies

Baking cookies is a fun and delicious activity, but having the right equipment can make all the difference. In order to make perfect cookies every time, there are a few essential tools you'll need. First and foremost, you'll need a mixing bowl and a sturdy whisk or wooden spoon to mix the ingredients together.

You'll also need measuring cups and spoons to accurately measure out the ingredients, as well as a baking sheet to place the cookies on. A cooling rack is also important to prevent the cookies from getting soggy after baking.

Finally, some recipes may call for additional equipment such as a cookie scoop, piping bag, or rolling pin. Having these basic tools on hand will ensure that you're ready to make delicious cookies whenever the craving strikes.

For arranging cookies on a cookie tray, consider having a large platter or tray, baking parchment paper. A set of small tongs or a spoon can also be helpful for picking up and placing delicate cookies, while a small knife can be used to trim any rough edges.

Having equipment ready can make the process of baking and arranging cookies much smoother and enjoyable.

Recipes for The Best Christmas Cookie Trays

Simple Nutella Cookies
Hazelnut spread is the perfect ingredient for a Nutella Cookie recipe. Growing up Nutella was a staple in my house, right next to the butter, eggs and white toast bread.  So what's better than Nutella spread? The answer is Nutella Cookies!
Like Nutella? Try my Homemade Brownies with Nutella, Nutella Puff Pastry Turnovers or my Nutella Ice Cream (ice cream maker not required)
Get recipe for Simple Nutella Cookies
Nutella Cookies on a wooden cutting board

Maple Walnut Cookies
These Walnut Maple Cookies are perfect for Christmas tray bakes. Hints of maple in a buttery shortbread topped with royal icing and sprinkles. Who can say no to these delicious walnut butter cookies. Perfect for giving away on a Christmas cookie tray.
Get recipe for Maple Walnut Cookies
Maple Walnut Cookies in a brown plate

Crunchyy Ginger Snap Cookies
Is there anything better than a Crunchy Ginger Snap Cookie? I love these cookies because they smell so good as they are baking and taste even better once they are out of the oven and cool enough too eat.
Like cookies? Try my Mom's Recipe for Calabrese Chinulille, Italian Biscotti with Hazelnuts or my Italian Orange Cookies.
Get recipe for Ginger Snap Cookies
Soft Ginger Cookies on a wooden board with ginger

Soft Amaretti Cookies
Soft Amaretti also known in Italian as Amaretti Morbidi are a traditional Italian cookie made from ground almonds. Not only are they chewy and soft, but they are also gluten free.
Like Italian cookies? Try my recipe for Italian Orange Cookies, Almond Crescent Cookies, my Nonna's S Cookie Recipe or Italian Peach Cookies.
Get recipe for Soft Amaretti Cookies
Soft Amaretti Cookies stacked on a white counter

Simple Peanut Brittle Recipe
Who doesn't like a good Peanut Brittle recipe ?  The perfect candy for adults - sticky, sweet and nutty! This peanut brittle makes a great addition to any holiday baking platter.
As an Italian, also we cherish our Almond Brittle with Honey made every Christmas.
If you like cookies, try my recipe for Italian almond Brittle with Honey, Italian Orange Cookies, or my Italian Peach Cookies.
Get recipe for Peanut Brittle
peanut brittle in a glass

Easy to Make Coconut Macaroons
These are by far the easy to make Coconut Macaroons to make. So simple to make that a toddler could make them with their eyes closed.  Made with less than 6 (six) ingredients these Coconut Macaroon Cookies will be ready as fast as one, two, and three…
If you love the scents of coconut and vanilla together, you will love other cookies like Soft Amaretto Cookies, Italian Orange Cookies, Italian Peach Cookies or my Crunchy Ginger Snap cookies.
Get recipe for Coconut Macaroons
coconut macaroons on a cutting board

Easy Chocolate Peppermint Wafers
If you like the flavor of chocolate and peppermint then you will absolutely love this Easy Chocolate Peppermint Wafers. Made with four or less ingredients, options for making these Chocolate Wafers Cookies are endless.
Get recipe for Peppermint Chocolate Wafers
chocolate peppermint wafers

Orange Cranberry Cookies
I call these "don't break my heart" Orange Cranberry Cookies mostly because they are cookies baked in the shape of a heart and it's just cute to add a little spin on a cookie name.  These Orange Cranberry cookies make a great cookie to add to your Christmas Cookie collection or to make throughout the year even Valentine's Day!
Get recipe for Orange Cranberry Cookies
Orange Cranberry Cookies on a plate

Butter Cookies dipped in Chocolate
Italian Butter Cookies Dipped in Chocolate have always been a staple in my family especially around the holidays. This is a traditional Italian Butter Cookie recipe. 
These Italian Butter Cookies dipped in Chocolate are not just a treat for the taste buds; they are an exquisite celebration of textures and flavors that turn a regular shortbread cookie into something extraordinary.
Chocolate Dipped Italian Butter Cookies make the perfect cookie for your Christmas cookie tray. And if you are looking for something that can be ready in a jiff, try my lemon cookies made from box cake mix - seriously delicious. 
Get recipe for Italian Butter Cookies
Italian Shortbread Cookies on parchment paper
Why is it important to grease a baking tray?

It is important to grease a baking tray before baking cookies or any other baked goods because it helps prevent the baked goods from sticking to the tray, making it easier to remove them without damaging their shape or texture.

How can I stop things from sticking to baking trays when I am cooking?

You can stop baked goods from sticking to baking trays by greasing the baking sheet. You can also line the baking sheet with parchment paper and avoid overcrowding your unbaked goods. Non stick trays are also available which prevent baked goods from sticking to the surface.

What types of trays are used to bake cookies?

Cookie sheets or baking sheets are commonly used to bake cookies. These are flat sheets made of metal, usually aluminum or steel, with a rimmed edge to prevent cookies from sliding off the sheet. Non-stick baking sheets are also available, which have a special coating that helps prevent cookies from sticking to the surface. Silicone baking mats are an alternative to traditional baking sheets that can provide even heat distribution and prevent cookies from sticking to the surface.

Desserts You'll Fall For

  • frutti di bosco on a wooden cutting board with one slice removed
    Frutti di Bosco Tart
  • Italian Torrone with Nuts FI
    Soft and Chewy Italian Torrone (Nougat)
  • Single Serve Desserts Collage
    Single Serve Desserts Perfect for Two
  • baked nutella muffins on a kitchen towel
    Homemade Nutella Muffins

PIN IT Here

Christmas Cookie Tray PIN for Pinterest

More Cookie Recipes

  • chinulille on a red plate FI
    Mom's Recipe for Calabrese Chinulille
  • Biscotti Savoiardi in a China Plate FI
    Savoiardi Ladyfinger Biscuits
  • Orange cookies on a white plate
    Italian Orange Cookies Biscotti All'Arancia
  • cookies in a green plate
    Nonna's Italian S Cookies Recipe

Comments

    Leave a Reply Cancel reply

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

    Recipe Rating




    This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

  1. Vijitha says

    December 20, 2020 at 8:14 pm

    Wow! This is like a one-stop for Christmas cookies - So many types to choose from, perfect for making gift boxes! I love it that you also took time to include packaging tips 🙂 Thanks a bunch for this round up!

    Reply
  2. Julia Pinney says

    December 16, 2020 at 1:52 pm

    So many great cookies in this collection. I'm pretty sure I'd eat one of each..easy! I love the tips for packaging as well. Great Christmas round up!

    Reply
  3. Nicoletta De Angelis Nardelli says

    December 16, 2020 at 1:19 pm

    Cookie boxes with a good variety of cookies are my weakness! Here there are so many great cookies to choose from! My favorite being the Italian butter cookies dipped in chocolate! 🙂

    Reply

Recent Recipes

  • Pork Braciole in a white plate drizzled with Pesto Sauce
    Italian Pork Braciole Stuffed with Prosciutto & Ground Beef

  • fried chicken cutlets in a white plate
    Easy Italian Chicken Cutlets

  • peas and mushrooms in a white plate
    Italian Peas and Mushrooms

  • Veal Piccata garnished with sliced lemons and parsley
    Italian Veal Piccata

  • Sauteed Kale and Potatoes in a white plate
    Sautéed Kale and Potatoes Recipe

  • steak pizzaiola in a white plate garnished with parsley
    Steak Pizzaiola Recipe

SIGN UP FOR OUR NEWSLETTER
and get ready to take your puff pastry game to the next level with our FREE e-book, because life is too short to settle for mediocre pastries.
Yes! Send me a FREE eBook, I want to make pastries like a pro!

This page contains affiliate links, which means I may receive commissions if you choose to purchase through links I provide (at no extra cost to you). Thank you for supporting the work I put into this site! As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

About Me

Picture of Amy Outside

Hey, I'm Amy! And I'm so happy you're here!! So many of my favorite memories in life seem to take place around the table, especially when surrounded by the people I love. And of course, all the better when nourished by some seriously delicious food.

Stick around and explore the site to get great ideas.

Learn more about me →

Affiliate Links Message

*This page may have affiliate links, which means I may receive commissions if you choose to purchase through links I provide (at no extra cost to you). Thank you for supporting the work I put into this site!

  • Paleo

  • Whole30

  • Desserts

  • Main Entrées


  • Poultry

  • Meatless

  • Seafood

  • Beef

Footer

↑ back to top

About

  • Privacy Policy
  • About Me

Newsletter

  • Sign Up! for emails and updates

Reach Out

  • Contact
  • Work With Me

Copyright © 2025 Easy Homemade Recipes
Cook'd Pro using the Feast Theme Plugin